Adult learning faces unprecedented challenges. It is vital that everyone lets Welsh government know their views.
The Welsh government has asked for ‘evidence’ to inform its consideration of the future of tertiary education. The scope is enormous, covering the learning of around 300,000 people in Wales’s colleges of further education, universities, 6th forms, apprenticeships and adult community education. With huge changes taking place in the economy and society, as well as challenges within the tertiary education sector itself, this is a call that should not be ignored.
The Welsh government paper identifies four main challenges: participation and equality, demographics, competition between institutions, and financial pressures. Some of the challenges are seriously worrying.
In terms of learning itself, there will soon be fewer young people in the population and rising numbers of learners are studying low level qualifications. People from low-income backgrounds are less likely to engage in learning, and if they do they study lower-level qualifications and have higher drop-out rates. And across the board, Wales has lower participation than England.
In terms of institutions, as independent bodies too many are competing for students and cutting courses leaving gaps in provision. Most are facing considerable financial pressures. It is a perfect storm – and one which has been brewing for some time.
The consultation paper is surprisingly easy to read as Welsh government papers go. It is measured in tone, and draws extensively on statistical and other evidence. So far so good.
On the downside, it is overwhelmingly managerial in approach. There is no vision of what post-16 learning is for – it is all about making the current educational system work more efficiently and effectively. Implicit in most of the paper is that learning is for economic benefit, and because of this economic focus, the benefits of learning in later life are completely overlooked.
But most worrying of all is the absence of learners’ voices from the discussion – the focus (and request for evidence) is very much on ‘stakeholders’. Cost of living pressures are noted, but no mention of learners’ views about expectations, experiences, barriers and opportunities. No asking WHY so many learners at lower-levels drop out of studying, no asking WHY applications to higher education at age 18 are so low. It is worth reminding Welsh government that it should undertake a Children’s Rights Impact Assessment in respect of any firm proposals.
This is a vitally important and timely review that affects the future of everyone who lives in Wales. The stakes are too high to leave to vested interests – so do please respond by 27 March. The paper is here: The future of tertiary education in Wales: five challenges and calls for submission | GOV.WALES

Leave a Reply