You have to hand it to the self-catering industry – it is remarkably good at getting stories about the “unfairness” of taxes in the media. Last week yet another story popped up, this time on North Wales Live, about how a pensioner was struggling because of new Welsh government rules on holiday lets. The article was heavy on the heart strings, but light on any facts or figures and devoid of any counter arguments.
So I thought I’d find some myself.
At the centre of holiday lets owners’ complaints is the issue of council tax and business rates. Over the years, canny owners have registered their holiday homes / lets as businesses, and therefore pay business rates not council tax.
To check out the difference this makes, I found a holiday cottage on Castle Street, Criccieth. It’s a pretty little two-bedroom home, that’s currently up for sale as well as being available to rent. In Council Tax band C, it has a liability of £2,079 as a main residence. As Gwynedd applies a 150% premium to second homes, the liability increases to £5,197 if it is not occupied as a primary residence. But, like almost all properties in the street, it’s registered as a business. This means that the owner pays no local taxes at all, thanks to small business rates relief on properties with a rateable value of less than £6,000. Even without small business rates relief, the standard business rates liability would be lower than standard council tax.
The Welsh Government tightened the requirements on holiday homes in 2023, increasing the number of days a holiday unit has to be commercially let if it is to claim business rates from 70 out of 140 days to 182 out of 252 days. It is this rule that is generating the media stories.
Is it really unfair? Are the new criteria too tough?
It is surely right that anyone claiming business rates relief on a property should have to prove they are running a proper business from it. Claiming small business rates relief reduces local taxes to nil and shifts the cost of providing local services – from which small businesses benefit – onto the rest of us.
The question then is whether 182 days too many. It’s undoubtedly a big jump from the previous 70 day requirement. But, looking at recent occupancy rates in the self catering sector, it’s not unreasonable. The Wales Tourism Barometer shows self catering units in Wales have an average of 69%, 77% and 80% occupancy in June, July and August 2025. In winter, the Barometer shows that occupancy stood at 58%, 53% and 60% in October, November and December 2025 respectively. These figures ought to be sufficient to achieve the 182 day requirement.
It is important to note that these figures are the averages, and so some holiday lets will have lower occupancy. The industry claims that 40% of businesses do not meet the threshold. But, and this is the crucial issue, if a business is not functioning at a reasonable level of economic activity, why should it get a year free of local taxes?
Being unable to achieve the required occupancy level doesn’t stop anyone running a holiday business. It just means that the business no longer gets a tax break and has to pay local taxes. In many parts of Wales, that local tax is exactly the same as the amount paid by local residents, although in some there is a premium for holiday accommodation.
There are some gremlins in the system, and the Welsh government is currently considering responses to its consultation on easing some of the requirements on the industry. But to me, the fundamental principle is right – everyone should pay local taxes, and exemptions, if any, must be fair to everyone. And that includes the majority of the population who face amongst the highest Council Tax bills in the Britain!
So next time you read a story in the media about the unfairness faced by holiday cottage owners, remember that the real issue is about tax breaks on paying for local services, and who should get them not the unfairness faced by Ms Jones or Mr Williams.

Leave a Reply