For Wales do not see England: why comparisons of public spending and services are flawed

, ,
Child holiding Welsh flag

A new report by the Institute for Fiscal Studies has put a cat amongst the pigeons.  It compares total public spending, and spending and performance on health and education, in Wales with England, and concludes that public services are worse despite the Welsh Government spending more money per person. With just weeks until the Senedd election, it is potentially political dynamite.

Now, I am usually a big fan of the IFS and am no apologist for the Welsh government.  But the key findings didn’t sit right with me, so I read the whole thing and mulled it over.  And while the analysis is probably right, in my view the context is not. 

How much money?

The report makes much of the fact that total expenditure per head on public services is higher in Wales than in England. Of the expenditure, £17 of every £100 spent is on social security, with around half of that being on state pensions. In other words, at least some of that ‘extra’ spending is simply because Wales has a lot of pensioners! So not exactly because of UK ‘generosity’ but because lots of older people live here.

The report goes on to note that devolved expenditure per head is also above that of England. This should surprise nobody: Wales has had higher devolved spending per head since the 1970s . Why? For the very good reason that it has significantly higher levels of need than England. The authors do acknowledge higher needs in Wales but nevertheless press on and for almost all the report the key comparison is Wales vs England. 

UPDATE: Wales Fiscal Analysis suggest that the IFS has substantially overestimated Wales’s funding relative to England’s. Far from receiving around 125% of England’s per capital allocation, WFA finds that it is around 115% – namely the level that Wales was estimated to need to take account of demographic, social and economic differences.

In fairness, the report does compare Wales with the north east of England in some places.  The authors say this region is similar to Wales.  Hmm. Wales may be more like the north east of England than, say, the south east, but there are still important differences.  We have a greater proportion of people aged 65+, a larger number of disabled people, and a population density that is twice as sparse – all of which increase the need to spend on public services. So Wales is similar to the north east of England but not sufficiently so for a direct and a truly fair comparison.

My own starting point is not that ‘Wales gets more per head than England’ but ‘does Wales get enough to meet its needs’ and why does Wales gets so much less than Scotland and Northern Ireland’?  I guess it all depends on where you sit – and the report is clearly England-centric.

Filling gaps in UK spending

The report points out that UK government expenditure in Wales is important, accounting for around 40% of all public spending. What it doesn’t point out is that Wales gets very limited amounts of UK spending on, for example, R&D and transport.  And when UK spending has been cut, for example on working age social security, Wales has been disproportionately affected. 

These shortfalls leave the Welsh government picking up the bill. The most obvious example is rail transport. Professor Mark Barry has ably documented the huge underfunding of rail infrastructure in Wales. To see any improvement, the Welsh government took responsibility for the core valleys network and is creating a south Wales metro using its own and EU monies. A different example is successive UK government’s freezing Local Housing Allowance (paid to help low income private sector tenants with their rent) which has contributed to rising homelessness, costing Welsh local authorities around £1 billion in temporary accommodation costs alone.

Unfair comparisons

A key element of the analysis is the comparison of health and education services in Wales and England. The authors conclude that the performance of Wales’s public services is lagging behind. I don’t think many would argue that some – perhaps many – of Wales’s public services urgently need improvement, and I’m not trying to defend the Welsh government or anyone else.

But I do think that comparing Wales with England is like comparing chalk and cheese – it’s simply not something you can do meaningfully because of demographic, socioeconomic, and environmental factors. Take the example of health.  It is well known that older people make greater demands on health and social care services, and so the more older people you have in the population the greater the demand for outpatient appointments and hospital admissions.  Older people often have multiple conditions, and so their care is often more complex, requiring a longer stay, and if they need support after their hospital treatment then social care needs to be put in place.  More than one in five people in Wales is aged 65 or over (21.7%) compared with one in six in England (18.7%). Those three percentage points make a big difference to need for health and care services, yet are not taken into account by the IFS report.

Selective indicators

The report uses various indicators of performance, such as hospital waiting lists and educational participation and attainment. These are key issues and it’s right to include them – but the devil is in the detail.

Take the measure of the proportion of 18-year-olds going into higher education. According to the IFS, only 29% in Wales do so, compared with 39% in England. This is pretty shocking, but it’s a bit more complex than it first appears. As UnisWales points out, progression to HE at age 18 varies across the UK, and Wales is not alone in having below average rates – in fact the proportion entering HE is slightly higher Wales than the north east England.

It’s also worth noting that entry into HE at 18 is not the only way to learn. A more meaningful measure is whether someone has entered HE by the time they’re 30. Medr estimate that in Wales the likelihood of someone having entered HE by the age of 30 was 54.6%. In England, with a slightly different methodology, 47.5% of 15-years-olds from 2008/09 had entered HE by the time they were 30. So while there is still cause for concern about recent trends in HE entry, Wales’s performance is at least as good as England’s on this broader measure.

Devolution in action

That there are differences in public spending and public services should not be a surprise. It’s the whole point of devolution! Sure, nobody wanted devolution to result in worse services, but it can certainly result in different services. Little account is taken of this in the IFS analysis, in which England is the norm.

To illustrate this point by continuing the higher education example, a Welsh Government might have decided to invest in higher level vocational, technical or work-based learning rather than in entry into full-time higher education at an HE establishment. A lower HE participation rate of 18-year-olds would therefore be a policy choice – a different way of achieving a skilled and educated population – rather than a performance issue.

Concluding remarks

The IFS analysis of public spending in Wales fuels a narrative that public services are rubbish despite getting a disproportionate share of funding. I am categorically not excusing Wales’s NHS waiting lists or the low-levels of educational attainment – if nothing else I and my family have suffered from both. But a different – and equally credible – narrative could be that Wales has disproportionately high levels of need for public services which is not adequately reflected in levels of public spending on either devolved or non-devolved functions. Wales’s public services are struggling to meet demand and to improve – on some measures its performance is worse than in broadly comparable parts of England, but on others it is better.

What we need in Wales is a fairer allocation of public resources combined with a major programme of public service improvement. Simplistic comparisons with England serve nobody well.

Comments

Leave a Reply