Ending child poverty: why a Welsh child payment is vital but not enough alone

Child's hands counting money on a wooden floor

Wales’s record on child poverty is dismal. Despite sixteen years of Welsh Ministers having a legal obligation to try to eradicate child poverty, three statutory child poverty strategies (2011, 2015 and 2024), regular progress reports and no end of champions, groups, summits and networks, the proportion of children living in relative income poverty has remained stubbornly high.

Wales’s record is not that surprising. Child poverty is usually measured by family income, yet the Welsh Government has no powers over social security and until recently chose not to use the powers it does have over devolved grants and allowances. It is no surprise that child poverty rates in Wales have pretty much tracked those in England.

That is set to change with the introduction of Cynnal – a weekly additional payment for families with children in receipt of Universal Credit. This is an absolutely vital step. Evidence from Scotland (including the Scottish Government’s evaluation and studies by academics at Glasgow and Manchester Universities) points to the reduction in the headline poverty rate, as well as reductions in material deprivation and food insecurity, and improved mental and physical health. As modelling by Policy in Practice showed, of all the different options, a child payment would have by far the biggest impact on poverty in Wales.

The poverty gap is huge

Unfortunately, some families are so far below the poverty threshold that a child payment is simply not enough to lift them above it. The JRF has calculated that a couple with two primary-school-aged children living in deep poverty would need an extra £10,900 a year – £200 a week – to reach the poverty threshold while those in very deep poverty would need an additional £13,500 a year.  

This yawning gap makes eradicating child poverty a very big challenge indeed. A child payment of £25 a week is in my view affordable – it would cost around £187 million if paid to approximately 145,000 children – less than 1 per cent of the Welsh budget. But increase the weekly payment, and Cynnal would account for an increasing share of Welsh public spending, so that at some point there would need to be trade offs between a child payment and, say, expenditure on education, social services or the environment. Even the Scottish Government, with its relatively more generous Barnett settlement, has held its child payment at £28.20.

The poverty gap is simply too big for a devolved administration to close through a child payment alone. What else might the Welsh Government do?

Help with housing costs

Housing costs are a big driver of poverty in general, including child poverty. There are around 160,000 children in poverty before housing costs are taken into account. Once rent or mortgage payments are factored in, an extra 35,000 or so children are pushed into poverty. And while the risk of being pushed into poverty is greatest for children children who live in in the private rented sector, the number of children pushed into poverty is largest in the social rented sector.

The Welsh Government can use its housing powers to help to reduce child poverty – measured by relative income – as well as to make sure every child has a decent, secure home. Providing a good quality social home will be a big help, especially for children stuck in temporary accommodation or for those in the private rental sector with unaffordable rents. But the Welsh Government needs to look at rents in the social housing sector too.

More needs to be known about why social rents are pushing some families into poverty, but the Welsh Government has powers (with local authorities) to make up shortfalls caused by the ‘bedroom tax’/no spare bedroom subsidy, through Discretionary Housing Payments (DHPs), if this is the cause. It also sets standards for social landlords’ rent setting, although the most recent – issued by the last government – covers the period up to 2036, leaving the current government with limited room for manoeuvre. It can also use DHPs to make up any shortfall in help with rent costs caused by freezing Local Housing Allowance in the private rental sector.

Support for greatest needs

At risk of stating the obvious, not all families are the same. The challenges faced by a working couple with three children in a secure social home are very different to those faced by a lone parent with a baby living in a women’s refuge. JRF’s analysis of poverty in Scotland, for example, shows that the Scottish Child Payment and other family payments have not had as much impact on poverty in families in certain groups (large families, families with a baby, lone parent families, families where someone is disabled, ethnic minority families and young parents) as on others. It mainly attributes this to access to the labour market and experiences within it, as well as to the UK social security system.

This finding is really important, because it makes clear that policies on supplementing income need to be linked with other policies on, for example, childcare and employment and training. For example, in Scotland around half of children in poverty live in a family where someone is disabled. So unless there is appropriate childcare for disabled children and access to decent work for disabled parents, there will be little change in these families’ circumstances. There is also a strong case for ensuring that public services to support vulnerable families are in place and effective.

Place matters

Last, but very definitely not least, the Welsh Government needs to consider differences in the prevalence and experience of child poverty in different areas of Wales. While there is child poverty in every part of Wales, it is highest in Wales’s cities – Cardiff (34.9%) and Newport (35.3%) – and the heads of the valleys (Blaenau Gwent (35.6%), Merthyr Tydfil and Torfaen (both 32.5%)). Growing up without much money AND in places where there are likely to be few children’s playgrounds, summer play schemes or decent public transport doubles the disadvantage that children experience.

Locally-based and driven support to reduce poverty and mitigate its effects must be part of the Welsh Government’s tool box. This is not about reinventing Communities First, or the long-forgotten ‘Children’s Zones’ (which I don’t think ever went beyond statements in the Senedd anyway), but practical, local authority, health board, school and college, and third sector collaborations.

What next?

The path towards a Welsh Child Payment is not smooth. While the Welsh Government has the powers to make the payment, it is unclear if it has either the budget or the ability to stop DWP and HMRC taking a chunk of the payment from families. The focus in the next few months is likely to be on overcoming these hurdles – but it should not distract attention from other measures that the new Welsh Government should take.

It must use every lever it has to reduce child poverty, especially deep poverty, and mitigate its effects.

Comments

Leave a Reply