Whatever you think of new PM Andy Burnham’s announcements in his first week in office, they have come at quite a speed and with a significant reach. £45 off your electricity bill might not be much for many, but for people who eke out their heating it means an extra two hours a day of warmth over the winter.
This focus on what Jonathan Friedland in the Guardian has termed ‘retail politics’ is a smart move. Already I have overhead people asking when the £2 bus fare will apply to their journey (which as an aside was £3.70 single to go 4.3 miles). The answer to the man and woman on the no.81 bus is that it doesn’t apply in Wales, because Burnham’s bus fare announcement, like two of his other headlines, applies only in England.
Now, you can criticise Burnham for not making clear what impact his announcements have on Wales, and you can criticise news outlets for fudging what’s devolved and what isn’t. But even so, Burnham’s slew of announcements puts the Welsh Government on the spot.
The Welsh Government has not been asleep during Burnham’s first week. From Monday 20 July to Sunday 26 July it issued 19 announcements, including a welcome to Burnham (insultingly short IMHO at 117 words and somewhat tardy on day 4 of his tenure). The Welsh Government’s announcements covered important current topics such as drought and wildfires, as well as new grants to increase disabled access in tourism and hospitality, welcome Tour de France riders, and a Nofio Ysgol programme to increase water safety for children.
But despite their volume, the Welsh Government announcements don’t have anything like the resonance for ordinary people that Burnham’s do.
Last week’s Welsh Government announcements are small in scale (£2m for disabled bedrooms and toilets in hotels and cafes) and slow in delivery (3 year roll out to give children in years 4 and 5 swimming lessons). Many are of little direct impact like the National Food Strategy which promises a ‘a transformational whole-system approach to linking up food policy’. Hardly likely to be the topic of conversation on any bus.
Notably, there is nothing that pushes back at Burnham’s announcements.
I get that telling the Welsh electorate that they’re still going to have to pay £3.70 to go 4 miles is not going to win votes, but reminding them that they get free prescriptions and their primary school children get a free lunch even if they have to pay a bit more on the bus might. I also get that Plaid would not want their agenda set by Westminster, but nor can they ignore it either – the agenda is set whether they like it or not.
A high profile PM who mixes up UK-wide, GB-wide and England-only policies is a challenge for any devolved government. All the more so if they are from a different political party, with a different understanding of devolution. Nevertheless, if Burnham is to continue to announce changes that appeal to Welsh people but apply only in England, the Plaid Welsh Government will need to work out its response, at speed and which cut-through.

Leave a Reply